Step into the eerie world of Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden with the haunting case “Prudence in All Things,” where a French spy’s secret past and a vengeful ghost entwine in a chilling mystery. Uncover cryptic messages scrawled on walls, follow spectral trails through shadowy forests, and confront restless spirits as you unravel the truth behind Prudence Hake’s tormented life-and death. Will you bring peace, banish the restless, or blame the living? Every choice echoes through New Eden’s cursed lands in this gripping story-driven Action-RPG experience.
You’ll solve these mysteries by figuring out what led to the haunting, what’s keeping the ghost hanging around, and, finally, giving the ghost a proper sendoff. Usually, this involves finding several hints to determine the intent of both the haunted person and the ghost.
“Prudence in All Things” haunting case focuses on Prudence and Thomas Hake. Our Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden guide will walk you through finding every hint and intent in The Woodfolks “Prudence in All Things” haunting case.
’Prudence in All Things’ location in Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden
The “Prudence in All Things” haunting case in Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden takes place during the game’s fifth chapter, “The Woodfolks.” Players begin by investigating Prudence’s cabin located in the northwest area of town, examining key items like a cooking pot, a letter, and writings revealed by interacting with objects inside the house. Following a map leads to the “three oaks,” where Prudence speaks in French, and players then follow a trail of numbers that uncovers memories and clues about the ghost haunting the area. The case culminates in confronting the ghost, engaging in combat, and uncovering the truth behind Prudence’s story. At the end, players must make a significant choice to either blame Prudence or ascend/banish the ghost of Thomas Hake, decisions that impact the narrative and character fates.
You’ll find the “Prudence in All Things” haunting case during the game’s fifth chapter, “The Woodfolks.”
When Red and Antea find their way through the Dark Woods and come to the Hunters’ Camp, Kate Newsmith – Thickskin’s sister – tells Red he’ll have to prove his worth to the settlers in the camp. There are two haunting cases that will do just that – “Prudence in All Things” and “Hammer and Tongs.”
If you ask around town, you’ll learn about the cook, Prudence Hake, and that she’s usually wandering the woods looking for food and flavors. You’ll find her house in the southwest corner of the camp.
’Prudence in All Things’ hints and intent in Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden
The “Prudence in All Things” haunting case in Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden revolves around investigating the mysterious past of Prudence Hake, a French woman suspected of sabotaging the New Eden colony by destroying food supplies. Players explore her house, follow a trail of cryptic numbers, and uncover hidden secrets, including encrypted messages revealing Prudence’s true identity as a French spy. The case culminates in confronting the ghost of Thomas, Prudence’s devoted husband, whose restless spirit haunts her. The player must then make a critical choice: blame Prudence, ascend Thomas peacefully, or banish his spirit, each decision influencing the broader narrative and Antea’s fate. This haunting case combines investigation, supernatural encounters, and moral dilemmas, emphasizing the game’s themes of prudence, sacrifice, and the consequences of one’s actions.
There are a total of six hints and two intents to find during “Prudence in All Things.”
- There’s lots going on inside Prudence’s house. You’ll get your first hint for Prudence from the letter on the table along the east wall.
- From there, head out into the woods heading west. You’ll find Prudence along the river and get her second hint from the conversation with her.
- As you continue west, head to the marker along the south side of the path. You’ll find a cave and a book inside hidden behind a destructible wooden barrier. Smash it and read the book to get Prudence’s third hint and her intent.
- Continue west-northwest to the other marker. This time you’re looking for a cave a little west of the river. Inside, watch on the right for a pedestal and reveal the memory there – no ritual needed. You’ll pick up Thomas’ first hint.
- You’ll have to fight your way through some nasty specters as you follow the wisps of stain to Thomas’ body. When you find the chisel, you’ll get Thomas’ second hint as well as his tie.
- You’ll find Thomas’ ghost – no ritual needed here either – just to the northwest of the chisel. You’ll get his third hint and intent from the conversation.
’Prudence in All Things’ choice in Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden
In the “Prudence in All Things” haunting case in Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden, players investigate the mysterious past of Prudence, a French woman linked to sabotage and tragedy in the colony. The case involves exploring Prudence’s house, following clues and a trail of numbers, confronting a ghost, and uncovering the truth behind the haunting. At the conclusion, players face a critical choice that shapes the story: they can blame Prudence, leading to her sacrifice and aiding in Antea’s resurrection; ascend Thomas, releasing his ghost peacefully and contributing to Antea’s ascent; or banish Thomas, forcing the ghost away and also affecting Antea’s fate. Each decision carries narrative weight and impacts the characters’ destinies, making “Prudence in All Things” a poignant and meaningful part of the game’s haunting cases.
The end of “Prudence in All Things” asks you to make a decision for The Closure of the haunting case. After talking to Thomas, Prudence will show up and you’ll have to choose to:
- Blame (and kill) Prudence.
- Gently ascend Thomas.
- Forcefully banish Thomas.
Will uncovering Prudence’s secrets change my approach to haunting cases
Uncovering Prudence’s secrets in Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden does influence your approach to haunting cases, but primarily in terms of narrative consequences and character relationships rather than radically changing gameplay mechanics. Discovering the truth about Prudence and her deceased husband leads to a key choice: either kill Prudence, which angers her husband’s ghost and triggers a hostile encounter, or send the spirit to the afterlife, gaining her trust and unlocking a side mission that deepens the story. This choice affects how certain NPCs interact with you and the availability of subsequent quests, but it does not drastically alter the core mechanics of investigating or resolving haunting cases.
More broadly, your decisions in haunting cases-including how you handle spirits and living characters-align with an overarching oath you take (Ascension or Resurrection), which shapes the tone and some consequences of your journey. While choices related to Prudence contribute to this narrative path, the game allows some flexibility, and your oath influences character attitudes and story outcomes rather than locking you into a single playstyle.
In summary, uncovering Prudence’s secrets enriches the story and offers meaningful choices that affect relationships and side content, but it doesn’t fundamentally change your investigative approach to haunting cases themselves.
Will learning Prudence’s secrets alter my moral choices in haunting cases
Yes, learning Prudence’s secrets in Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden can alter your moral choices in haunting cases by deepening the narrative context and influencing your decisions about how to treat spirits and the living. Discovering the truth behind Prudence’s past reveals morally complex situations that challenge your sense of justice and compassion, prompting you to choose whether to punish or forgive, which reflects broader themes of morality in the game. These choices affect character relationships and plot outcomes, encouraging players to weigh moral considerations carefully rather than simply following a fixed path.
This aligns with psychological research suggesting that uncovering others’ secrets-especially those involving moral violations-can provoke moral outrage and motivate punitive decisions, even when loyalty and privacy norms are at stake. In the game, this dynamic is mirrored by how revealing Prudence’s secrets influences your judgment and the consequences you face, highlighting how moral emotions shape decision-making in haunting cases.
In summary, Prudence’s secrets enrich the moral complexity of your choices, making your approach to haunting cases more nuanced and emotionally charged.
