Just when fans feared the worst, Hulu has surprised viewers by keeping one of its most acclaimed series right where it belongs-on your watchlist. At a time when streaming shakeups are leaving audiences anxious, Hulu’s decision to stick with this fan favorite proves some good news is still possible for TV lovers.
There was once a time when you could stream Over the Garden Wall on Max and Hulu. Last year that changed: Starting Sept. 1, it was scuttled from Max and only available on Hulu. And this year, the winds of change briefly got even more dire, with Over the Garden Wall creator Twitterthat Hulu was removing the show now as well – a huge blow considering it was the last place to legally stream it with just a subscription.
Thankfully, the rock facts came just as swiftly as the cause for alarm: McHale updated on Friday saying that after all that Over the Garden Wall was not leaving Hulu.
Who knows why the gods of streaming saw fit to shuffle this one off another platform just at the time we need it most, even temporarily, but it’s as good a reason as any to remind us to find a way to ring fall one way or another, with all its ephemerality, weather – or streaming services – be damned.
You need only spend a few minutes with Wirt (Elijah Wood) and Greg (Collin Dean) to understand why these two brothers are the perfect companions to ring in the season. Lost in some woods – dubbed “the Unknown” – they happen upon one conundrum after the next, each one more alternately spooky or spoopy than the last, as they struggle to make their way home.
Over the Garden Wall excels at flitting back and forth between a fantastical world and one far more like our own. It doesn’t take long for Wirt and Greg to feel like your own travel companions, with everyone in awe of the vividly drawn world in their own way (Greg, for instance, completely jibes with it). You stumble upon a town where all the people have pumpkin heads and sing a harvest song while dancing around an autumnal maypole structure. Maybe it is “some kind of weird cult where they wear vegetable costumes and dance around a big thing,” but who cares! They seem nice enough. But maybe Beatrice (Melanie Lynskey), the talking bird you’ve arrived with, is right, and it’s something far darker and more mystical.
Where other shows might feel the need to rush to define the world, Over the Garden Wall simply is, jumping rope with that line as it bounds through its Unknown. It’s a charming liminal space, and if audiences are game to indulge it, they’ll find the unraveling of the mysteries Greg, Wirt, and Beatrice encounter rewarding.
With Wirt’s worry and Greg’s easy delight, Over the Garden Wall elegantly balances the dual feelings of changing seasons. Like any claymation Christmas special, it is true seasonal programming; Max (and briefly Hulu) should know better than to let it exit when the cool winds of fall are just around the corner (hopefully). While it lives on elsewhere, no one should have to subscribe to every streaming channel just to keep up with the fruit of the season, and even then still miss the crispest autumnal tiding out there leaving it no longer legally streaming anywhere. But, as Over the Garden Wall teaches us, sometimes it’s worth undergoing some hardship to find the sweet reward at the end. So mark your calendars: It’s Autumn August now. Happy harvest, all.
Over the Garden Wall was once streaming on Max and Hulu. It’s now officially just streaming on Hulu, or you can buy it for about $10 on Prime Video.
Update (Sept. 20, 2024, 12:39 p.m. EDT): This post has been updated to reflect that Over the Garden Wall is, for some godforsaken reason, streaming even fewer places now.
Why did Hulu keep one of its top shows despite the timing being so bad
Hulu chose to keep one of its top shows despite the poor timing because the show remains a significant fan favorite and a valuable part of its content lineup, even amid broader streaming shakeups and controversies surrounding other series. While some shows or episodes have been removed from Hulu due to problematic content or timing issues, this particular show’s retention reflects Hulu’s recognition of its importance to viewers and its ongoing appeal, outweighing the risks of removing it at a sensitive moment.
Why did Hulu choose to keep the show despite its controversial episodes being removed
Hulu chose to keep the show despite removing some of its controversial episodes because the series as a whole remains a fan favorite and an important part of its lineup. The removed episodes, such as those from It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia involving blackface and other racially insensitive content, were pulled due to their problematic nature and the backlash they generated. However, Hulu retained the rest of the series because it is fundamentally a satirical show that critiques the very bigotry and ignorance portrayed by its characters. The humor is self-aware and aims to expose societal flaws rather than endorse them, which has allowed the show to continue without being canceled. Fans and critics recognize the nuance in the show’s approach, which balances offensive content with clear condemnation of the characters’ actions, making the series valuable enough for Hulu to keep despite the timing and controversy.
